BARGAIN RHONE: Vieux Donjon 2015

With many of the tiny production, mega-cuvée Châteauneuf du Papes now commanding crazy money, one can lose sight of the incredible value this region offers. The truth is that the Rhône arguably offers a quality/value ratio unmatched throughout France, if not the whole of Europe; in a recent Rhône review for Antonio Galloni’s VinousMedia website, Josh Raynolds sums it up perfectly: “in many cases these releases come far closer to the quality of their limited-production high-end siblings than price differentials would suggest.”

One of the very best value, traditionally-styled Châteauneuf du Papes is the brilliant Vieux Donjon. The Domaine is owned by Lucien and Marie José Michel, with the winemaking now firmly in the hands of their talented daughter, Claire Michel – who cut her teeth at California’s Harlan Estate before taking over the family business. The wine is a powerful, traditional, but beautifully concentrated style with the potential to age for 15 or more years, particularly in the top vintages; we have tasted mature examples which have retained beautiful shape, fruit and structure.

Rather than confusing matters with multiple bottlings, this is a straightforward operation: they produce just one red Châteauneuf du Pape and a limited quantity of white. The red is always a rough blend of 75% Grenache, 10% Syrah, 10% Mourvèdre and the balance a mix of other local varieties. The total production is a mere 4,000 cases, roughly half that of Chateau de Beaucastel.

Jeb Dunnuck is a huge fans of the Domaine that he considers as follow “Along with a small handful of other estates, I consider Claire Michel’s le Vieux Donjon at the top of the heap when it comes to classic, age-worthy and traditionally made Châteauneuf du Papes.” We’ve long been huge fans of these wines too and believe that at this price, the 2015 is an unapologetic steal.

  • Price: £310.00 per case
  • Pack Size: 12 x 0.75L
  • Status: IB
  • Quantity: 25 Cs
  • ETA: Autumn 2017
Buy it!

Tasting Notes and Scores

Wine Advocate
95

I loved the 2015 Châteauneuf du Pape from Claire Michel and it’s a classic blend of 75% Grenache, 10% Syrah, 10% Mourvèdre and 5% Cinsault, mostly from rolled stone terroirs, that was partially destemmed and brought up all in foudre. It’s a downright sexy, voluptuous 2015 offering textbook notes of kirsch liqueur, ground pepper, herbes de Provence, and incense. It picks up more dark fruit with time in the glass, is full-bodied, has plenty of fat and glycerin, and ample tannin, although they’re so polished you have to hunt for them. This gorgeous example of traditionally made Châteauneuf du Pape that’s going to drink beautifully for 15+ years. Jeb Dunnuck <>

Previous Recommendations

Tomatin Warehouse 6 Collection: 1975
One of Scotland’s Unsung Heroes
Bollinger La Grande Annee 2008
"A regal and heroic Bollinger" - RJ
Akitu Pinot Noir 2016
Our Favourite New Kiwi Pinot
2005 Imperial Gran Reserva in Jero
95 Point Ex-Bodega Release
Dom Ruinart 2007
'A Stunning Champagne'
2015 Galia Villages
95pt Spanish Bargain
A Festive BI Single Malt Treat
Tomatin 2009 1st Fill Sherry Cask
Vina del Olivo, Contino 2016
Incredible Single Vineyard Rioja
NEW RELEASE: Clarendelle Rouge 2014
By Haut Brion
The Mascot 2013
Baby Harlan, Promontory and BOND
CVNE Imperial Gran Reserva 2011
96pt Gran Reserva Rioja to rival the 1953
Clos des Goisses 2009
NEW RELEASE
Rafael Palacios As Sortes 2016
'The finest vintage to date'
Henriot Blanc de Blancs Jeroboam
2008 base year Champagne
Vina Real Gran Reserva 2011
97pt Gran Reserva Rioja Royalty
Chateau Grand Village 2010
A Bordeaux Bargain
Louis Roederer Brut Premier NV
Baby Cristal - £280 per 12 IB
Les Fillottes 2015
Baby VCC just £220 per 6!
"Vina Ardanza" La Rioja Alta 2009
95Pts for under £16 a bottle!
Ch Arton Armagnac La Reserve
France’s Best Eaux de Vie
La Chenade 2014
Phenomenal value from Denis Durantou
Haut Bergey 2002
Silver Oak Alexandra Valley 2013
CNDP Cuvee VV La Janasse 2015
“The 2015 is a tour de force" RP
Clarendelle Rouge 2012 (Haut Brion)
Second Coming: £145 per Jero!
The Greatest Ever Muga ‘Prado Enea’
UK Exclusivity
Esprit de Pavie 2011
Baby Brother of Chateau Pavie
Clos Apalta 2014
Awarded 100 points by James Suckling
Leroy Bourgogne Blanc 2015
Your favourite House White is Back
Lopez de Heredia
The Pioneer of Rioja
Orma 2014
"Challenger to Sassicaia and Ornellaia"
Zarate Albarino Balado Vineyard 2015
Sun in a Bottle
Christian Drouin Pays d’Auge 1989
The World’s Best Calvados - Made Better
Vina Ardanza La Rioja Alta 2008
94 Points for under £15 a bottle!
Get ready to Rock out the Rose
Rock Angel Rose from Esclans
Latour 2005 Ex-Chateau
"a spectacular effort" 98pts RP
BI BARGAIN: Clos L’Eglise 2006
One of the last vintages of a fine estate
NEW RELEASE: Pol Roger 2008
"Admirably long. Really exciting." 18/20 JR
NEW: Single Cask 1979 Rum
Exclusive Bottling Only at BI
BARGAIN BURGUNDY 2015
Outstanding Bourgogne Rouge from Leroy
NEW: Imperial Gran Reserva 2010
"A very good vintage for this bottling."
Jaboulet Crozes Hermitage 2010
"the best buy in the Northern Rhone"
DON'T MISS! Jadot Clos Vougeot 2015
"a Clos Vougeot that will go the distance"
TOP TIP: Guigal La Doriane 2015
Under 1200 cases produced in 2015!
Bollinger La Grande Annee 2007
"One of the three best from this vintage"
Krug Grande Cuvee
The Latest Innovation from Krug
BARGAIN RHONE: Vieux Donjon 2015
"the top of the heap" JD
Latour 2007 Ex-Chateau
"a fine Latour" (NM)
Best Buy: Haut-Brion 1999
"style only Haut-Brion appears capable" RP
NAPA LEGEND Clos du Val 2013
"a real head turner" AG
Clarendelle Blanc 2015 (Haut-Brion)
Without doubt the bargain of the vintage!
Casa Castillo Pie Franco 2010 – 95 Pts
"world-class wines from Spain" LG
Exclusive Hine 1986 Vintage Cognac
Released for H.M. The Queen’s 90th
Drouin 2000 Early Landed Calvados
A dangerously delicious piece of history
NEW Vin de Constance 2012
The Very Pinnacle of South Africa
Latour 2000 & Forts 2009 (2016 Release)
"truly great wines" JS
Cambon La Pelouse 2000
"equivalent to many classified growths" RP